Home » Tickets

Click on the button below to be taken to our secure purchasing site!


Mystery Cafe BBB Business Review

Preview of steps to acquiring tickets to fun

Page one: Choose show.
Page two: Enter # of tickets you want. Choose a date. Click Best available
Page three: Everything look good? Click continue.
Page four: Click on the circle to choose Box Office Will Call Office
Page five: Fill out the info and click on Finalize Order.
Or forget all this and call 317 684-0668 and talk to Joe about tickets.
He is there Wednesday – Saturday.

With your purchase you get the Dinner, Show and Coffee or tea or soft drinks and the gratuity for the server is taken care of for food service.

Extra are bar drinks and a gratuity for your server’s drink service.

Appetizers are available before the show starts. They are extra.

Ticket prices are based on the dinner you wish to enjoy.

$60 a ticket
Penne Pasta Primavera – Spinach, artichoke heats, mushrooms, and tomato relish sautéed with basil pesto, olive oil, garlic, parmesan cheese, and penne pasta

$64 a ticket
Chicken Normandy – Sautéed chicken breasts with mushrooms and sliced Granny Smith apples in a brandy cream sauce.  Served with rice pilaf

$67 a ticket
Maple Bourbon Pork Chop – Thick cut, bone in chop brushed with a house made maple bourbon glaze.  Served with a baked potato

$67 a ticket
Baked Walleye – Flakey walleye filet baked with seasoned bread crumbs and drizzled with a lemon Chablis butter sauce.  Served with rice pilaf

$70 a ticket
Ribeye – Twelve ounces of beautifully marbled steak.  Served with a baked potato


Had a wonderful time . Fun ..friendly ..good food. Actors terrific. Thanks Joe for your directions . Would definitly recommend for a great evening of laughter. Peg Ferry



What an awesome evening with great family and friends. Dinner was delicious and the mystery theater was so much fun. Loved seeing families having a great time together. I think my favorite tonight was a little girl, maybe 10 played a part speaking Pig Latin. Robin Gerth

We came to Indy for the weekend to shop for prom dresses and learned that one of our favorite dinner and show venues was sold out for the evening. We quickly researched the Internet and found the Murder mystery cafe. We decided to give it a try and boy are we glad we did. We had 2 17-year-olds, their mom, aunt grandma and all five of us loved the performance. Food was excellent. Next time we want to each have a part. Great job actors and servers! Cathy Macke