Great entertainment ~ We enjoyed it very much and the food was delicious! Thank you all!


Jan Worth and friends

Thank you soo much, we had a really good time.Have a GREAT day!!


Joe Vrska

We truly enjoyed ourselves Saturday night and will plan to attend again soon! Appreciate you allowing us to attend Saturday night. It was my daughter’s birthday and it made for a fun evening.


Martha Huber

Went here on Saturday night with a friend. It was a thoroughly entertaining way to spend an evening. The show keeps you entertained the whole night, no matter what the size of your party. It’s silly, so not for those who take themselves too seriously. LOTS of audience participation, so if you’re not willing to “ham it up”, watch out. But, if you’re willing to get into it and be silly, it’s a ton of fun to get involved.


Lauren M., Chicago IL

 Click on the button below to be taken to our secure purchasing site! 

Homicide for the Holidays

Welcome to the Plumberman Family Holiday Reunion! It's a thrill to have so many members of the Plumberman family in one place at one time. This year's family holiday reunion is extra special as we have gathered to celebrate the release of our matriarch, Grammie Plumberman from the pokey! It'll be a holly jolly holiday for sure when we see Grammie's face light up like a Christmas tree as she is greeted by all her loving family members on this most wonderful; time of the year.

Then what to my wondering eyes should appear?! A stealthy shiv causing oh so much fear! Someone shivved Grammie on the day of her release! Who? And Why? And how? Well, we know how, but who and why? Poor Grammie and poor Plumberman family! This happy event has turned into a Homicide at the Holiday Family Reunion!

Tickets to fun in Indianapolis

$68 a ticket

With your purchase you get the dinner, show, drinks (coffee, tea or soft drinks) and the gratuity for the server is taken care of for food service.

Extra are bar drinks and a gratuity for your server’s drink service.

Appetizers are available before the show starts. They are extra.

The dinner includes your choice of the entrées listed below plus your choice of soup or salad and cheesecake is served as dessert.

Penne Pasta Primavera – Spinach, artichoke heats, mushrooms, and tomato relish sautéed with basil pesto, olive oil, garlic, parmesan cheese, and penne pasta.

Chicken Marsala – Lightly breaded chicken breasts smothered in our house made Marsala mushroom wine sauce and topped with a sprinkle of parmesan cheese Served with rice pilaf.

Maple Bourbon Pork Chop – Thick cut, bone in chop brushed with a house made maple bourbon glaze. Served with a baked potato.

Baked Walleye – Flakey walleye filet baked with seasoned bread crumbs and drizzled with a lemon Chablis butter sauce. Served with rice pilaf.

There is a Prime ticket for $78. It includes the same as the $68 ticket however you get to upgrade your entrée to steak!
Ribeye – Twelve ounces of beautifully marbled steak. Served with a baked potato.

Just a fun-filled evening. We brought with us a very special young man who has been through a lot of difficult things in his home life. He was so excited to be there and I think it sparked an interest in him to get involved in drama at his high school. Thanks!


LuAnna B.

We came to Indy for the weekend to shop for prom dresses and learned that one of our favorite dinner and show venues was sold out for the evening. We quickly researched the Internet and found the Murder mystery cafe. We decided to give it a try and boy are we glad we did. We had 2 17-year-olds, their mom, aunt grandma and all five of us loved the performance. Food was excellent. Next time we want to each have a part. Great job actors and servers!


Cathy Macke

Had a wonderful time . Fun ..friendly ..good food. Actors terrific. Thanks Joe for your directions . Would definitly recommend for a great evening of laughter.


Peg Ferry

What an awesome evening with great family and friends. Dinner was delicious and the mystery theater was so much fun. Loved seeing families having a great time together. I think my favorite tonight was a little girl, maybe 10 played a part speaking Pig Latin.


Robin Gerth