Have a Group of 20+ Looking for a Good Time?

FIND OUT MORE!

Let us share the Mystery Cafe interactive murder mystery dining experience with you and your group in a public or private show!

NOW PLAYING: Peggy Sue Got Murdered

January 10-May 31

BUY TICKETS!

The ‘Welcome Back to Elizabeth High School Sock Hop’ goes terribly wrong when the most popular girl in school, Peggy Sue is murdered. The Big Copper and his assistant Teen Angel investigate the murder at a school where all the characters from your favorite songs attend.

Welcome to The Mystery Cafe

The Nation's Longest Running Murder Mystery Dinner Theatre

Mystery Café started this unique style of dinner theatre in 1990 in Boston. Since then we have entertained over a million people in 30 cities across the US., and are beginning our 19th year here in Indy. Each play unfolds in four acts, with a course of the meal served after each one. Members of the audience may participate as much, or as little, as they like in the mystery. Upon arrival, you'll be met at the door by the evening's characters, who will help you find your seats and your new identity. Fifteen to 20 guests have lines to read during the play, and some are given a song to sing. When the first scene starts, keep a watchful eye open for clues, and jot down anything that looks suspicious. At evening's end, we give a prize to the person who best solves the mystery. We also give a prize to the biggest ham...uh, well...the best actor or actress from the audience. Every performance is unique because the audience is so directly and deeply involved. The magic lies in the interaction and unbridled creativity which occur in a room full of people who began the evening as strangers, but go home as friends.

Forget the Date, Bring an Alibi!

Public Shows on FRIDAY and SATURDAY NIGHTS at the Milano Inn!