Frequently asked questions about the Mystery Café

Questions answered below are:

  • Why?
  • What do you eat?
  • What do you wear?
  • How involved?
  • How get tickets?
  • Where located?
  • What are the times?
  • How about kids?
  • The Price?
  • Off site private show/parties?

Why choose Mystery Café?

All work and no play make Jack & Jill dull. It is FUN!!!

Thank YOU very much. We had a blast!

Good Food

Great entertainment ~ We enjoyed it very much and the food was delicious! Thank you all!
Jan Worth and Friends!

What do I eat?

Soup or Salad
Your choice of a House Side Salad or Chef’s Soup Du Jour served with our Fresh French Baguette.

The Main Event

Penne Pasta Primavera – Spinach, artichoke heats, mushrooms, and tomato relish sautéed with basil pesto, olive oil, garlic, parmesan cheese, and penne pasta

Chicken Marsala – Lightly breaded chicken breasts smothered in our house made Marsala mushroom wine sauce and topped with a sprinkle of parmesan cheese

Maple Bourbon Pork Chop – Thick cut, bone in chop brushed with a house made maple bourbon glaze.  Served with a baked potato

Up Graded ticket
Ribeye – Twelve ounces of beautifully marbled steak.  Served with a baked potato

Classic Cheesecake ~ A local favorite made in-house.
Any dietary restrictions can be accommodated. Please make sure to let your wait staff know upon your arrival and when placing your drink order.

What do I wear?

Dress is casual, but nice. Sometimes we have what we call the optional “Fun Dress” where you arrive in costume to complement the theme of the evening’s mystery. So really the dress code is you must wear clothes, there are just some mysteries we don’t want solved.

Will I be involved?

Audience participation is the driving force behind the Mystery Café. However, participation is strictly voluntary. We look for 15-20 volunteers to play minor characters in our show with speaking parts. All you have to do is stand up at your dinner table and read you lines. Of course we encourage you to “ham” it up. Remember, we can’t do the show without you!!!

Loved it had a great time I even won the Golden Hammy first time the President character every won this.
Antonio Brown

Where do I get tickets?

You can Buy Tickets to Fun or call our Box Office at (317) 684-0668. If you have more than 20, call our Group/Private Sales Line at (317) 937-9689, and we’ll hook you up with our group rate discount!

Where are we located?

Our public performances are located at The Library Restaurant & Pub at 2610 S Lynhurst Dr. on Saturday evenings.

What are the times of the shows?

We seat at 7pm and begin the show at 7:30. The shows take place in the upstairs banquet rooms of the Library Restaurant & Pub.

Seating is officially at 7pm but the room is available by 6:30 for those wishing to arrive early to enjoy some fine appetizers from the Library Restaurant. Appetizers are not included with the ticket and will be added to your drink bill.

The restaurant does not have an elevator so we hope you can do stairs.

What about Kids?

Yes bring your kids with you. There is no nudity or profanity in our shows. The innuendoes are like the jokes in the Shrek movies. The actors loved to have kids play parts. The owner is a former Circus Clown so ask him to juggle for the kids. The Kids price is $25 for 13 and younger. Have a real young one? As long as the child does not order a dinner but eats off Mom or Dad’s plate no ticket is needed. We had a two year old play a part because he had to say 3 words. “I am Root.”

Family Friendly

This little boy’s part in the show was to laugh at all the jokes. For doing so he was awarded his own Hiwaiian shirt.

How much are the tickets?

$65 a ticket which includes your dinner: choice between Penne Pasta Primavera – Chicken Marsala –Maple Bourbon Pork Chop –Baked Walleye. The show, coffee, tea, soft drinks and gratuity.

Extra costs would be adult beverages and appetizers if you so choose.

$25 a ticket for Kids 13 and younger.

$72 a ticket will allow you an upgrade to enjoy the Ribeye Steak as your dinner

Do you offer onsite or offsite parties??

Absolutely! Call our Group/Private Sales Line at (317) 937-9689. Find out more on our GROUPS & PRIVATE EVENTS page.

Hi there…
We had a terrific time, by the way!! We will definitely recommend the experience to others!
Laura Eisenbarth
Sales Assistant-TCU Investment Services